I put up a post like this before concerning 2005 Red Sox and Indians team cards. I'm in the process of reorganizing my Phillies cards and noticed a similar thing. Here's the Phillies team card from 2005 Topps.
As near as I can tell (you may disagree) the rest of the picture is identical in the two cards. So what's going on here? Topps having fun with photoshop (to what purpose?) or the Phillies messing around during team photo day?
Since I've seen this on 3 different team card pairs, I'm inclined to think it's Topps.